More than 100 members of the community group Goleta Parents for Tech Reform have signed a letter calling on the Santa Barbara Unified School District to strengthen its proposed tech policy to include concrete reductions in technology use.
The School Board will vote on the “Tech with Intent” policy at its Tuesday night meeting. But the proposal isn’t strong enough for many of the families that have been pushing for stricter limits on items such as screen time.
“Language defending “instructional flexibility” suggests that a staff person can simply override the screen time limits,” the letter reads. “There is ZERO accountability.”
The drafted policy, which does not impose hard restrictions on how much technology can be used in the classroom, reflects a lack of public consensus on how much students should be learning on iPads.
Instead, the policy provides screen time recommendations but gives teachers the option to exceed them.
Steve Venz, chief operating officer, said the district will write grade-specific screen-time limits directly into its administrative regulations. Mandatory digital literacy instruction and an annual superintendent report on implementation of the policy will also be part of the policy.
“We are writing the administrative regulations with staff so the guidance reflects what students need in each grade and subject,” Venz said. “Research and national guidance on screen time keep changing, and keeping the numbers in the AR lets the district update them as needed.”
How the District got here
The district’s position on tech use in schools has become one of the most contested and closely followed issues by students, parents and teachers who all offer differing views on technology’s role in education.
What’s happening in Santa Barbara Unified is a window into an issue impacting public school districts nationwide, as they grapple with moving past digital learning structures built for the COVID-19 pandemic.
As research on the impacts of screen time on children circulate among parents and teachers, the onus is on school districts to protect students from the harms of excessive tech use while preparing them for the future.
In May, nearly 50 parents packed the board meeting and overflow room urging trustees to adopt LAUSD’s own “tech with intent” policy — a north star for Santa Barbara Unified — which implemented screen time limits per grade. They also called on the district to install content filters on student devices, ban recreational platforms like YouTube and overall reduce its reliance on technology for learning.
The following month, the district banned YouTube on student devices along with other non-instructional Google platforms including Google Translate and Google Maps.
Students — especially one San Marcos High School senior — were not happy.
Mateo Gallegos, in the days following the ban, surveyed over 300 students at his high school who were overwhelmingly said they were against the district restricting YouTube. Gallegos grew his student body coalition and expanded his survey to Dos Pueblos and Santa Barbara high schools, which led to the same conclusion.
A majority of students surveyed said YouTube is a valuable learning tool, and that a sweeping ban of the platform along with other Google services negatively impacts their learning. They also said the new restrictions and available alternatives were not properly communicated to them.
Over the summer, the district installed new content filters on junior high iPads and passed a non-binding resolution outlining its rollout of technology changes moving forward, including the adoption of a board policy in October.
At the beginning of the school year, the district joined a national lawsuit against tech giants Meta, Google, TikTok and Snapchat for fueling a mental health crisis among young people.
Forthcoming technology regulations include a third-party security audit of all district-issued devices, a kindergarten-through-twelfth grade digital citizenship course and options for junior high parents to configure their students’ iPads.
The district’s chief operating officer said parent choice configurations will be tested in-office in November and December, and then at school sites.
“The parent choice configurations are in active development, said Venz. “It is going slowly, but that is because it is not an out-of-the-box solution.”
