The Santa Barbara Unified School Board voted to redraft its “Technology with Intent” policy at its Tuesday meeting — further stalling on one of the most pressing education issues of the year — concurring that the section on grade-specific screen time recommendations needs to be specified.
Board member Gabe Escobedo motioned to assign two board members to work with district staff to update the board policy and bring it back to the board for a vote, which passed unanimously.
Before the board came to the vote, the hour-long debate on the dais was whether the board should take more time to get its “Technology with Intent” policy right, or to take action for the sake of moving forward.
“I was super pleased to see a board policy presented with the administrative regulations because I understood the impact of my decisions on the schools,” said board member Sunita Beall. “But now I’m sort of like, here’s this broad policy…I’m not hearing what we’re doing differently at different grade levels.”
Board members Beall and Celeste Kafri, as well as student board member Victoria Martinez Peneranda will work on re-drafting the policy.
Tuesday night was the first time the “Technology with Intent” policy was presented to the school board. It read that students should follow grade-specific screen time limits, but does not say what those limits are.
District staff said that the policy is intentionally broad, and that specific screen time recommendations would be written into the accompanying “administrative regulations,” which governs how the district implements the policy.
Escobedo argued that the board policy should be redrafted to better reflect the district’s “Technology with Intent” resolution that it passed in July. The resolution said the district would recommend grade-level screen time limits and give parents the choice to opt-out of certain technology use for their students.
“We are going to get hung up on the board policy because otherwise, we’re asking to just trust that the [administrative regulations] are going to meet the intent of the board’s resolution,” Escobedo said. “I think we have to be prescriptive in the board policy.”
The main skeptic of the motion was board president Bill Banning, who said he was happy to support the motion if the board was able to find a way “to get from A to B without running in circles.”
“I think we’re in a situation where we will be trying to build consensus about a very, very difficult issue to come to consensus,” Banning said.
Banning said he arrived at the meeting ready to vote on the first draft of the “Technology With Intent” policy, and expressed concern that the board would get caught in a loop of trying to please everybody.
“I don’t know if a doctor that tells us that there’s obesity caused by technology has more weight than a student that says not having YouTube opportunities hurts my education,” Banning said, referring to comments made on the item that night.
The board president made a motion to approve the policy as it stood, but failed to get a second.
Nearly 10 members of the public spoke on the item, and they reflected the lack of public consensus on technology’s role in education.
Kathryn Birch, co-captain for Goleta Parents for Tech Reform, arrived at the podium holding a signed letter from over 135 members of the community urging the district to re-write the policy to include plans for concrete reductions in technology use.
“We strongly advise the board policy more accurately reflects the hard-won specificities in that resolution that was passed in July,” Birch said.
Students Mateo Gallegos and Frida Salgado from San Marcos and Santa Barbara high schools, respectively, along with students from other high schools have been particularly critical of the district’s ban on YouTube.
“Some families can afford private tutors and computers, others cannot,” Salgado said. “Those iPads were supposed to level the playing field, and yet here we are banning access to one of the largest free educational resources available: YouTube.”
Gallegos and Salgado said the new tech policy should not be so restrictive that it disadvantages students without the same access to technology as their peers.
But parents said that students don’t always know what’s best for them.
“I haven’t heard anything from the pro side that makes it seem like we’re diametrically opposed on how to move forward,” said Kevin Kasch, a parent. “Maybe the implication that YouTube access should be returned in school. I bet kids would also love TikTok and Roblox if we’re going by survey says.”
Kafri suggested that Santa Barbara Unified students and members of Goleta Parents for Tech Reform be involved in the redrafting of the “Technology With Intent” policy.
“I think it is worthwhile to give us the additional time,” Kafri said. “We worked for more than a year on this tech committee. So I’d love to make sure that this policy is really on point.”
