When the over 200,000-acre Wildfire Risk Reduction Project was first released in 2022, it immediately sparked the concern of local advocacy groups such as the Los Padres ForestWatch.
The large-scale of the project and the fire suppression techniques—such as clearing, fuel breaks and prescribed burns—outlined in the plan threatened native chaparral plants and other vulnerable ecosystems found in the national forest.
Soon after the initial project was announced, ForestWatch worked to build an alternative, gathering a coalition of 90 community groups and multiple elected officials.
“We wanted to provide a solution, not just an objection,” ForestWatch Director of Advocacy Ben Pitterle said.
What happened next was mostly behind closed doors. There wasn’t a formal discussion between ForestWatch and the Forest Service, and they weren’t sure if the Service had taken its plan into consideration.
Four years later, the final approved Wildfire Risk Reduction Project was scaled back 86%, to 30,023 acres. While it wasn’t as large of a scale-back ForestWatch had hoped for, it was still a dramatic reduction.
“I would say that this project is a really great reason why these environmental review processes are so important,” Pitterle said.

The Los Padres Forest Service did not respond to multiple requests for comment regarding its consideration of ForestWatch’s alternative plan.
The scale back included revisions such as making fuel breaks thinner, smaller brush clearing areas and an overall more refined and targeted approach to fire suppression.
Concerns still remain
In remote areas of the Los Padres National Forest, where chaparral grows vibrantly, fuel breaks could still have permanent consequences.
“It is a known fact that repeatedly clearing chaparral will convert the forest into invasive mediterranean grasses,” Pitterle said. “Once you have those invasive grasses, that’s forever.”
While the Forest Service says that it will not be creating any new fuel breaks as part of the project, the plan includes the maintenance and clearing of current ones.
Pitterle said these will punch corridors that run deep into the forest for invasive grasses to spread.
He also said there are specific species that ForestWatch is concerned about. One of which is the Refugio Manzanita, a rare type of chaparral only found along the Gaviota coast and the coastal Santa Ynez mountains near Gaviota.
A fuel break will be positioned along the ridge near Gaviota, potentially damaging Refugio Manzanita’s already limited habitat.
With the Wildfire Risk Reduction Project being approved and designated as an authorized emergency action, the path forward won’t involve any more public comment or an objection period—largely barring further input from advocacy groups.
However, groups such as ForestWatch still intend to monitor the project to make sure the implementation stays in line with what was approved.
While Pitterle says ForestWatch isn’t fully satisfied with the final Wildfire Risk Reduction Project, they are pleased that the Forest Service implemented changes and community feedback before approval.
“For ForestWatch to put forward any type of alternative that involved vegetation removal, it was a significant step for us,” Pitterle said.
