Cottage Health nurses said Monday that hospital leaders have engaged in unfair labor practices, as tensions grew in the run up to a unionization election now scheduled for two days in early December.
A Wednesday filing alleges Cottage threatened to withhold raises if the nurses join SEIU 121RN, prohibited employees from using break time to speak with union representatives, and among seven other violations threatened to interrogate workers about their potential union support.
The allegations, which administrators of the nonprofit healthcare system refuted, emerged as the nurses announced the vote will be held Dec. 8 and 9.
Clare Upton, a pro-union Goleta Valley Cottage Hospital emergency room nurse, described a printed message displayed at Cottage and connected to the filing that, she said, implied annual merit increases and cost of living adjustments enjoyed by employees for 11 years in a row were no longer guaranteed.
“I have coworkers who quite literally live paycheck to paycheck. They have to get this money,” Upton said. “That to me is so disappointing.”

The charge was not yet assigned to an investigator, according to a Thursday letter to the union from the Los Angeles division of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB).
Responding late Monday to the union’s announcements, Cottage in a statement said the healthcare system respects the nurses’ right to choose.
“We disagree with these claims, take our obligations under federal labor law seriously and will respond to them through the NLRB’s process,” the statement said. “We encourage every eligible nurse to vote so all voices are represented. Whatever the outcome, we will continue working alongside our nurses to care for the community we serve.”
Simmering for months, grievances driving the unionization effort burst into the open on Oct. 23, when nurses at the forefront gathered with family members and elected officials outside Santa Barbara Cottage Hospital to announce the campaign.
Citing wages as one factor, the nurses said their average pay falls below statewide averages—making it difficult to rent homes along the South Coast, which leads to longer and more exhausting commutes.
The nurses also described a desire to improve working conditions and gain more transparency around benefits.
And while an existing shared governance model is valuable, enabling nurses to surface concerns about workflows and equipment shortages, it falls short of providing nurses a voice on wages, benefits and staffing ratios, they said.

As they nurses prepared to go public, Cottage administrators said the healthcare system as a desirable place to work, celebrated compliance with state-mandated nurse-to-patient ratios, and shared what they described as improvements to benefits programs.
Cottage leadership also noted only 8.2% of Cottage nurses left the system in the latest annual tally, compared to a Hospital Association of Southern California benchmark of 12%.
“Professional nursing is challenging,” Laura Canfield, Cottage vice president for patient care services and chief nursing officer, said at the time. “Nurses are highly valued at Cottage Health. They are the heartbeat of the organization. Their voices are incredibly important to us.”
Hospital administrators on Monday promoted Keep Cottage Together, a website the organization created. They also drew attention to an Oct. 30 op-ed article penned by several Santa Barbara Cottage emergency room employees.
“Nurses’ concerns about wages and working conditions are real, and every nurse deserves to feel valued, heard, and supported,” the article signed by 13 employees stated. “But we should also recognize the support our hospital already provides and consider whether continued collaboration, instead of an outside union, is the best path forward.”
If the union wins a majority of votes, SEIU will represent 1,300 nurses at Santa Barbara and Goleta Valley and Cottage Rehabilitation hospitals.
On Monday, the ER nurse Upton criticized Cottage descriptions of the union as a third party intermediary.
“I literally called SEIU,” Upton said. “I called SEIU for Goleta and my coworker called SEIU for Santa Barbara. It was literally me. They’re talking like I’m some scary monster coming in to mess everything up.”
The nurses are the union, said Upton, who’s expecting to give birth to her first child at Santa Barbara Cottage on Dec. 4.
“I’m planning to vote no matter what,” she said. “If you have nurses sitting at the table when you make decisions, that automatically positively affects everybody else. When nurses’ lives are improved, everybody wins.
“Regardless of how you feel about this, regardless of your vote, regardless of any of that, I want every single nurse to know that I will be continuing to fight just as hard for every single nurse,” Upton said. “From the very, very beginning of this entire process, this entire campaign, my full intention was to help my coworkers and improve our lives.”
As they seek collective bargaining representation, the nurses have noted Cottage reported $252 million in profits in 2025.
The union push comes as Cottage expands with an increased focus on addressing maternal health, children’s health and chronic conditions through strategies that include more outpatient services. The organization, for example, has plans for a $35 to $45 million Cottage Health hub in Buellton to fill Santa Ynez Valley coverage gaps.
That plan comes three years after the Sacramento-based nonprofit Sutter Health, a chain of two dozen hospitals and 200 clinics, expanded south to Santa Barbara County by acquiring Sansum Medical Clinic, an institution dating to 1921.
And it comes two years after UCLA Health opened a South Coast flagship facility on Victoria Street in Santa Barbara, growing its primary and specialty care footprint while incorporating a cancer care clinic. The organization also has a primary and specialty care center in Montecito.
Cottage administrators have acknowledged the healthcare system is profitable, emphasizing 52% of the organization’s 2025 profits went to wages and benefits.
