A flock of white turkeys gathered outdoors at a turkey farm.
Turkeys at the author’s local turkey farm. (Courtesy Nick Thomas)

This year, the United States celebrated 250 years since the adoption of the Declaration of Independence in 1776. Patriotic symbolism has naturally been on display: waving flags, marching bands, nationalistic songs, references to Uncle Sam, the Statue of Liberty and bald eagles, the latter being adopted as an official emblem of the United States a decade later.

As the well-known story goes, in a 1784 letter to his daughter, Benjamin Franklin wrote rather disparagingly of the now widely recognized avian American emblem. Comparing the eagle to the turkey he called the latter “a much more respectable bird and withal a true original native of America.” Of course, old Ben never seriously suggested installing the turkey as the National Bird.

But what if we had? The entire symbolic culture of the country could have evolved very differently. For instance, wild turkeys might have appeared on U.S. coinage, banknotes, stamps, passports, and other official symbols of America instead of the eagle.

Today, Eagle Scouts would be called Turkey Scouts, while golfers hitting a rare three holes under par would exclaim, “A double turkey!” The Screaming Eagles, which is the nickname of the U.S. Army’s 101st Airborne Division, might indeed have been screaming had they been dubbed the Screaming Turkeys. And could Pennsylvanian NFL fans really get behind the Philadelphia Turkeys?

In the music world, Don Henley and (the late) Glenn Frey might have remained unknown performers had they called themselves “The Turkeys.” That would not have evoked a peaceful easy feeling. Beloved American poet Walt Whitman might have been less loved had he published “The Dalliance of Turkeys” in 1880. And much later, in 1968, it would not have made Clint Eastwood’s day to star in the war adventure, “Where Turkeys Dare.”

Presidential addresses would be delivered from behind a White House lectern featuring a turkey on the Great Seal of the United States — although, given the history of Oval Office occupants, that might not seem entirely inappropriate to some voters.

Even the American space program would’ve been influenced. When Neil Armstrong transmitted the first message from the Apollo 11 lunar module after landing on the moon in 1969, he surely would have choked on the words, “The Turkey has Landed!”

Of course, eagles outshone turkeys in the symbolic pecking order. With their respective roles now firmly established in American culture, we can give thanks that both birds have served us well.

Nick Thomas has written features, columns, and interviews for many newspapers and magazines.