The rent freeze remains and relationships at City Hall are frigid.
The Santa Barbara City Council on Tuesday night voted to extend the rent freeze, which was set to expire Jan. 1.
Now, the rent freeze will remain in place likely until June when voters are tentatively set to vote on whether to repeal or support the city’s rent stabilization ordinance.
The vote capped a tense, emotional, and long meeting that began seven hours prior. No one appeared happy with the outcome.
“It’s just all bad,” said councilwoman Meagan Harmon. “The litigation, the threatened litigation, the risks, the stress, the uncertainty to tenants, to landlords, it’s really a difficult situation.”
The vote was 4-2, with councilmembers Harmon, Oscar Gutierrez, Kristen Sneddon and Wendy Santamaria in support of extending the rent freeze. Mayor Randy Rowse and councilman Eric Friedman opposed. Councilman Mike Jordan was absent.
The vote was the latest in a yearlong saga that has pit landlords vs. tenants, and strained relationships on the City Council. A year ago, the City Council passed what was supposed to be a “temporary” rent freeze, to buy itself time to create a rent stabilization ordinance. The council eventually approved a rent stabilization ordinance in October of this year.
But over the course of the past year, property owners sued the city to block the rent freeze, and then gathered signatures to block the rent stabilization ordinance. Opponents of the ordinance submitted more than 9,000 signatures to qualify it for the ballot.
Santa Barbara County is currently counting the signatures and if it determines that at least 5,500 people who signed the petition are valid Santa Barbara residents, the matter would go on a ballot for a public vote likely in June. The debate comes at a time of rising rents in Santa Barbara and an exodus of longtime residents, including a steady decline of working class Latino families.

Several property owners spoke at Tuesday’s meeting and criticized the city for maintaining the rent freeze.
“Let’s stop pretending this is about protecting Santa Barbara,” property owner Mimi Greenberg said. “What you are hellbent on doing is to turn Santa Barbara into a national poster child for rent control.”
Greenberg accused councilmember Santamaria of “sharing her chair with the tenants union.”
Santamaria was elected two years ago and has been a strong advocate for the Santa Barbara Tenants Union. Councilmembers Gutierrez, Harmon and Sneddon have long supported the rent stabilization ordinance, but it wasn’t until Santamaria was elected that the council had a fourth vote to actually pass an ordinance.
She said the council was unfairly targeting landlords.
“Somehow you expect private property owners to subsidize your political experiment based on your non-existent phds in economics,” Greenberg said. “You cannot morally justify that landlords provide another year of financial sacrifice.”
She added that the council was elected to “represent the entire town, not just the tenants union.”
“What you are doing is an abuse of political power,” she said. “It is an attempt to take money from one group of citizens to satisfy another group’s political demands.”
She called it theft.
“The four of you should be handcuffed and escorted out the back door,” she said. “And just an FYI, not so many years ago, thieves were hung in this town.”

Councilmember Santamaria denounced the comments later when she spoke.
“For a property owner to stand there and call us thieves even when federal judges say none of this is a taking, and then immediately saying it was a long ago in this town that thieves were hanged is quite honestly appalling political violence and has no business in this city”
Santamaria also sparred with councilman Eric Friedman, whom she sits next to on the dais. She gave him “permission” to be collaborative and support the rent freeze extension. She said the council might not be facing litigation and a referendum if he had attempted to be collaborative months ago.
Friedman took exception to her comments. He said he has worked to support elements of the ordinance, including pushing to have Santa Barbara Housing Authority properties exempted from the ordinance.
“I have been up here nine years, I don’t need to ask you for permission,” Friedman fired back. “If you had been willing to work with me and Mike Jordan at the time, we would have had a 6-1 vote, it would have passed in July and we wouldn’t be where we are. Whether you want to accept that responsibility, that is up to you.”
The rent stabilization ordinance, once it goes into effect, would limit annual rent increases to 60% of CPI, with a maximum of 3%, or whichever is lower.

The rent stabilization ordinance became the defining issue of the recent mayoral campaign where Sneddon narrowly defeated Friedman. Sneddon supported the ordinance, while Friedman opposed it.
Councilmember Sneddon on Tuesday night kept her comments brief, but expressed frustration that the city is facing a referendum. The referendum essentially forces the city to freeze the ordinance in place — and the city cannot change the ordinance until there is a public vote.
“Now that we are in the mode of referendum, we can’t make adjustments,” she said.
Santa Barbara Mayor Randy Rowse, who has consistently opposed the ordinance, said property owners should not be vilified. He said the city could have avoided a situation of litigation and referendums had the council worked collaboratively earlier in the process.
“Not only are there tenants living on the edge, there are small property owners living on the edge right now,” Rowse said. “Now we want to extend something based on our own faux paus.”

