The Santa Barbara Unified School District Board of Education decided on Tuesday not to let perfect be the enemy of the good. 

The board approved a $375,000 plan to hire a Director of Inclusive School Communities and a specialized ethnic studies teacher assigned to elementary schools to help create a culture of anti-racism on campus. Some board members wanted another ethnic studies teacher assigned to junior high school campuses. 

It was a win for a coalition of ethnic studies teachers and community partners, including Healing Justice, who erupted in cheers when board members approved the plan. 

But it took a bit of push and pull to get board members to put aside their differences on the details of the plan and move forward.

“I’m not going to support anything that doesn’t approve this position tonight,” said board president Bill Banning. “It needs to happen now with an expectation that if it’s not enough or it’s not right, we can fix it.”

Banning defended the plan and said that it includes support for junior high students — it just doesn’t center them. 

“I think it’s becoming pretty clear that we’re not doing enough,” Banning said. “It’s an accelerant not only for us, but for the members of the community, and everyone that comes and speaks to us to get us to a point where within one meeting, we went from a proposal to develop something to a meeting where we’re about to approve it.” 

The decision comes after a recent “blackface” social media incident at San Marcos High School.

Escobedo, who sits on the Black excellence committee, said the way the original plan was presented felt rigid, despite him agreeing with Banning that it needed to move forward. 

“I really, really implore us to stop thinking about defensiveness and control,” Escobedo said.
“There’s so much empowerment in partnership, in going to community, and going to other people.”

Tuesday night was Escobedo’s last meeting as a school board member, as he prepares to take oath as a new member of the Santa Barbara City Council in December. 

Escobedo took some of his final moments on the dais to criticize his fellow board members for not engaging in anti-racism and inclusivity work enough until recently. 

“We need to have some humility to understand that obviously we need other perspectives in this, because we have used our perspectives and we have fallen short,” Escobedo said. “It takes us to separate our self-worth from what we’re hearing in public comment to understand that what we’re hearing…is not a criticism of us as people.”

One member of the public said that the plan never passed through the district’s Black excellence committee. But the board room booed at trustee Celeste Kafri when she suggested that the board send the plan back to committee.

“This has to change. I 100% agree,” Kafri said. “I also think that the ethnic studies community has been working for more than eight years on this and we’ve got to get it right. That’s my perspective. So I think that we need to wait and send it back to [the committee] and make sure that it is correct.”

Before Kafri could finish, one member of the public yelled, “No! Approve the funding!”

Escobedo opposed Kafri’s suggestion.

“I would tell you that [the committee] would love the opportunity to have input on this,” Escobedo said. “But there is a feeling of frustration on whether there’s a lack of progress on all of the things that we wanted to do when we set our goals at the very beginning of this committee.”

He added: “This is the first time I’ve come to a meeting where there has been substantive proposals on the table that focus on the preemptive work.”

Nearly 25 members of the public spoke on the item, reiterating past comments made that the district needs to support ethnic studies and other resources to make all students feel included on campus.

“We need adequately funded positions responsible for advancing equity and anti-racist work,” said Alejandrina Lorenzano, an ethnic studies teacher at Dos Pueblos High School.

Haley Snyder, a former teacher at San Marcos High School, said that equity work shouldn’t fall on existing full-time teachers.

“There needs to be dedicated positions created at the district, elementary, junior high and high school level,” Snyder said.

Fabiola Gonzalez-Gutierrez, a founding member of the Ethnic Studies Now! Santa Barbara coalition, said the district needs to put its money where its mouth is. 

“We have moved forward beyond asking whether ethnic studies matters,” Gonzalez said. “We are asking whether this district will invest in its leadership and resources necessary to confront anti-Blackness and humanize all students, especially Black students.”

Julianna Lozada is a Santa Barbara-based reporter. She previously wrote for Southern California News Group as well as the Beverly Hills Courier and Santa Clarita Valley Proclaimer. She holds dual degrees from Sciences Po Paris and Columbia University.