One of Santa Barbara’s most iconic downtown properties is on the market—for an undisclosed sale amount.
Hayes Commercial Group announced on Thursday that the 90,0000-square-foot retail, restaurant and office space development is on the market. The area is home to Andersen’s Danish Bakery, Gallery 113, Lewis & Clark, and dozens of other prominent businesses.
“A property like La Arcada rarely changes hands, and when it does, the buyer tends to value its history and character as much as its economics,” said Francois DeJohn, founding partner at Hayes Commercial Group. “We expect strong interest from long-term investors, family offices and local stewards who recognize what it means to own a true Santa Barbara landmark.”
The sale comes at a time of dramatic change downtown, as the city transforms following the COVID-19 pandemic and a change in retail shopping trends. Yardi Systems is moving its corporate headquarters downtown into Paseo Nuevo and a housing project for the former Nordstrom building is working its way the process.
The plaza is also home to a 22-piece art collection that includes bronze sculptures designed by artist James “Bud” Bottoms. The fountain, featuring Amelia the Flying Turtle, is also a popular Instagram-worthy site for photos.
La Arcada opened in 1926 on the former site of Our Lady of Sorrows Church, which was destroyed in the 1925 Santa Barbara earthquake, according to a news release. The plaza was designed by architect Myron Hunt in the Spanish Colonial Revival character.
“With its arcades, tiled walkways, fountains and wrought-iron detailing, it remains one of the oldest continuously operated shopping courtyards in the American Southwest,” the news release states.
Hugh and Marjorie Petersen purchased La Arcada in 1973 and transformed it again, giving the Plaza its current look.
“La Arcada is one of a handful of properties that truly define Santa Barbara,” said Kristopher Roth, partner at Hayes Commercial Group. “For a century it has been where locals and visitors alike come to shop, dine and linger, and the Petersens’ care over the last fifty years is visible in every fountain, sculpture and tile. It is a rare privilege to help guide a property like this into its next chapter.”
The plaza has 76 businesses and upper-floor offices with professional tenants. The plaza is over 90% leased.
“La Arcada’s tenants, its boutiques, galleries, restaurants and offices, are what make the courtyard come alive,” added Caitlin Hensel, partner at Hayes Commercial Group. “Our process is designed to respect those relationships and the community’s connection to this place while giving qualified buyers a full understanding of the opportunity.”
In an interview with the News-Press, Hensel said about the listing, “We are really excited about it.
“The sellers have been committed stewards of this property and have built strong relationships with their tenants,” Hensel said. “We’re looking for a buyer with the same approach. With the property nearly fully occupied, the existing tenant base is a big part of its value.”
