The Santa Barbara Unified school board meets Tuesday, Nov. 17, in Santa Barbara. (News-Press file photo)

By The Charger Account Editorial Board (Dos Pueblos High School)

A new five-step racial incident response protocol, revised discipline matrix, and additional staff training were among the changes Santa Barbara Unified School District Chief Operations Officer Steve Venz presented to the school board on Oct. 27.

The proposals followed widespread outrage over a September incident in which four San Marcos High School students posted a racist TikTok depicting blackface. On Nov. 12, Venz emailed the SBUSD community outlining the new procedures.

Apparently, it took national headlines for the district to recognize the shortcomings in its approach to racism.

During the Oct. 27 presentation, district officials acknowledged that responses to racist incidents had been inconsistent across schools.

We are appalled that district leadership allowed such glaring inconsistencies to persist. Students should not have to wonder whether the consequences for racist behavior depend on which SBUSD school they attend.

The district’s original discipline matrix presented by Venz classified mocking or touching a Black student’s hair as just a “Level 2” offense, alongside “non-targeted” racial stereotypes, jokes, and slurs. Its prescribed response included administrator notification and interventions, but did not specify contacting families of the students involved or suspension.

We were dumbfounded that officials tasked with addressing racism found it acceptable to group racially motivated physical contact with “non-targeted” jokes. Touching a Black student’s hair carries a long history of white microaggressions. That district leaders charged with protecting students overlooked such an obvious distinction while drafting policy specifically intended to address discrimination is inexcusable. They also need to make sure all students are educated about the long history of racial oppression and marginalization tied to textured hair and hair styles originating from the African Diaspora.

Following feedback from the SBUSD Committee Advancing Black Achievement, Wellness, and Excellence (CABAWE), the district proposed moving racially motivated physical contact to Level 3, a category containing more serious consequences. Other revisions clarified family communication, student support, incident documentation, and suspension.

We commend CABAWE for identifying these glaring oversights, but we are disgusted that district officials needed them pointed out. District administrators should not need an advisory committee to explain the basics of responding appropriately to racism.

Venz said the discipline matrix had not been updated since 2019 or 2020, despite a reported violent racist incident at Santa Barbara Junior High School making headlines in 2022 and a series of racial incidents contributing to the establishment of CABAWE in 2024.

The district has had years of warning, yet it took another incident attracting national attention to prompt revisions. How many times must students and families publicly shame SBUSD into doing its job?

The public packed the Santa Barbara Unified School board of trustees meeting Oct. 13 urging the board to take action following the recent ‘blackface’ incident originating from a social media post uploaded bb a San Marcos High School student. (News-Press file photo)

A new policy means nothing until the district demonstrates that it will enforce it and be proactive about checking in on its efficacy. Students deserve better than another round of promises.

In a previous Charger Account column, two Black members of our staff described their frustration with the district’s handling of racist behavior. The members of this editorial board are not Black, but we do not need to be Black to recognize how atrociously our district has mishandled racism. We have every reason to expect better. We are owed better.

The district’s lack of transparency only compounds our frustration. On Oct. 16, The Charger Account submitted a California Public Records Act request seeking districtwide totals of documented and investigated race-based incidents at SBUSD high schools and their disciplinary outcomes. The district requested an extension on Oct. 26 and confirmed on Nov. 9 that “responsive records” existed, but said they would not be provided until around Dec. 9.

Nearly two months to obtain information about incidents the district claims to have been tracking for years as part of CABAWE’s work is absurd. After declaring racial equity a priority years ago, why is it so difficult to obtain basic information about the district’s response to racist incidents?

Without this data, we are left to take the district’s word that its efforts are working. It shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone that we are no longer willing to do that.

And discipline alone will never solve the problem. Schools must work to address the root of racism, not just react to it.

Education is one of the most powerful tools schools have to challenge bigotry. Students must understand the history behind blackface, racial slurs, and other discriminatory behavior. SBUSD must examine how its curriculum addresses racism and ensure staff training prepares educators to recognize discrimination, intervene, and support students. It should measure whether that training actually changes responses, rather than congratulating itself for simply mandating another training.

At Dos Pueblos High School, the new Culture and Climate Committee is bringing together students, families, and staff to examine school culture. We’re glad someone is addressing these problems before another incident makes headlines. But why hasn’t this been a priority until now? And are other schools working to be as proactive? Because DPHS can’t be alone in its efforts.

The responsibility for this pattern of inaction reaches the district’s highest levels of leadership.

Superintendent Hilda Maldonado has rightfully faced criticism over the district’s untimely and performative handling of controversies during her tenure. However her retirement does not absolve the school board of years of inadequate oversight.

Barbara Parmet, donning an ethnic studies t-shirt, supported a special assignment ethnic studies teacher at the junior high level during the Nov. 17 SBUSD school board meeting. The move comes in response to recent school incidents. (News-Press file photo)

Longer-serving members, including Bill Banning, Rose Muñoz and Gabe Escobedo, have served through years of repeated concerns about racism.

At the Oct. 27 meeting, Escobedo criticized the district’s reactive approach and called for dedicated personnel to coordinate its equity initiatives. We agree. It’s hard watching the district wait for something terrible to happen before scrambling to appear proactive. But Escobedo’s criticism is hollow without an acknowledgement of his own responsibility as a board member. He served on the very board responsible for holding district officials accountable. Where was his sense of urgency and call for greater accountability before national headlines or his campaign for a seat on the Santa Barbara City Council?

With Maldonado’s departure approaching, the board has an opportunity to appoint a superintendent who prioritizes prevention, transparency, and meaningful accountability. But replacing the superintendent means little if the board tolerates the same shortcomings under new leadership.

SBUSD has had years to address racism in its schools. We will not be applauding the district for taking steps it should have taken years ago. It should not take national outrage to compel a school district to protect its students. How many more racist incidents will it take before SBUSD stops performatively reacting and starts leading? The answer must be “none.”

Editor’s note: This editorial was originally published by The Charger Account, the Dos Pueblos High School student news site. On Nov. 17, the Santa Barbara Unified school board approved a $375,000 plan to hire an inclusion director and an elementary ethnic studies teacher.